Spar Weight Saving

Big Project

Project

Project Manager

Big Project

Project

Project Manager

Eclipse

Wings

@Nathaniel Li

Task Description

To save as much weight as possible, we’re looking to punch out a bunch of material from our spars. A discussion and some sims/calculations were done in discord https://discord.com/channels/776618956638388305/1274525728364564601/1292601797982163086 to determine optimal orientation of the holes.

Brief description of our findings:

  • Quick FEA was wrong to see which way would give us more strength

  • Remember that wing deflection is the main concern (ie. the wing deflects in the axis perpendicular to the “length” of the spar

  • Result: less deflection when hole is parallel to the force and therefore parallel to the ground (this is enough info for you to complete the task)

 

image-20241007-180513.png
Hole parallel to the face

 

image-20241007-165912.png
Hole perpendicular to the face
  • If you’re curious as to the theory and reason behind it, here it is (not necessary for the task):

    • Deflection formula for simple cantilever beam:

    • Since deflection is inversely proportional to moment of inertia, increasing moment of inertia reduces deflection; moment of inertia formula for a rectangle:

      •  

      • By having a weight saving hole, we are subtracting the moment of inertia of the hole

    • When the material is removed from the parallel face, the moment of inertia for the hole is:

    • From the perpendicular face:

    • From these formulas, the perpendicular hole has a largest moment of inertia and so it reduces the overall moment of inertia more (since it is subtracted from the total)

    • This leads to more deflection based on the deflection formula

Constraints

Constraints

Written By

Append Date

Constraints

Written By

Append Date

Holes should be on the faces parallel to the ground

@Nathaniel Li

Oct 7, 2024

Specific hole design is up to you but keep in mind the method of manufacturing since we already have the box tube

@Nathaniel Li

Oct 7, 2024

Assignees

Assignee

Asana Task

Date

Assignee

Asana Task

Date

@Ben Lovegrove

 

Oct 10, 2024

Task Progression/Updates

Author: @ person updating Date: YYYY/MM/DD

UPDATE TITLE

Include any updates here + reasoning