Skip to end of metadata
Go to start of metadata

You are viewing an old version of this page. View the current version.

Compare with Current View Page History

Version 1 Next »

The Phase 1 Design Paper (technical report) will consist of a written proposal submitted by each team describing the technical details of their proposed competition design. Design papers may be submitted in English or French


Scoring Criteria:

Design Paper

Score

Notes

Days Late

-10% per day

Applicable after 1700 EST

Overall Presentation

Weight: 15

Notes

Grammar/Spelling

Structure/Organization

  • Make sure the reader is presented with a clear story of what your system will do and how it will meet the competition requirements. Organize the paper according to the evaluation criteria

Use of Figures/Charts/Tables

  • have appropriate titles and labels

  • referenced from the text so reader know’s what it’s trying to show

References Provided/Correct

Technical Description of Unmanned System

Weight: 50

Be Sure To Include:

Analysis of Alternate Solutions

  • other ways the problem was approached

  • why we chose this solution

Features and Capabilities

  • what makes this design special

Pick-Up/ Drop-Off Methodology

  • what features this system has to allow for pickup and drop off of a range of design shapes

  • how this process occur gently, accurately and at a distance

Automation

  • how we meet the requirement for automated launch/flight to the intruders

Noise Signature

  • what UAV and/or navigational strategies are we using to minimize noise?

Safety

  • How we intend to avoid colliding with things

  • Any other safety systems implemented

System Level Testing

  • testing process implemented during development and in preparation for practice flights and scenarios

Technical Innovation and Novelty

Weight: 10

Be Sure To Include:

Novel Approach to Mission Requirements

  • How overall and individual strategy for completing tasks is novel. (NOT talking about technologies required - that’s something else)

Novel Elements

  • Novel technology systems in the overall system. (What does our UAS have that make sit novel in the execution of the Tasks)

Safety and Risk Management

Weight:15

Be Sure To Include

System Level Safety Issues

  • What safety issues are important

  • How we are addressing them

Single Point Failure Modes

  • What failure modes we anticipate

  • How we are addressing them

Risk Management Plan

  • What risks exist that may affect ability to successfully compete in Southport

  • How we are addressing these risks

  1. Risk categories should include technical, programmatic, budget, and/or others. Risk planning must include:

    1. Identification of the risk;

    2. Likelihood that the risk will happen;

    3. Impact on the project if the risk occurs; and

    4. Measures you will take to reduce the likelihood of the risk and to mitigate its effects if it does happen.

  2. Milestones - Key events in the project that signal things are progressing as planned

  3. Schedule - Gantt chart of all significant activities in the development of the system and planning for the event

  4. Budget - purchase of ‘stuff’ for the system (don’t forget to include travel and other things)

Project Management

Weight: 10

Be Sure To Include:

Milestones

  • Key events in the project that signal things are progressing as planned

Schedule for Design/Construction/Testing Phases

  • Gantt chart of all significant activities in the development of the system and planning for the event

Budget

  • Cost of ‘stuff’ for the system (don’t forget to include travel and other things)

NOTE: Papers are limited to 15 pages total, including appendices, title page, table of contents, list of figures, etc. Pages above the 15-page limit will be ignored in the scoring

The paper must be emailed to competition@unmannedsystems.ca in PDF format.

  • No labels