Chemistry

LiPo vs. Li-ion

Why Lithium:

  • lightest of all metals

  • has the greatest electrochemical potential

  • provides the largest energy density for weight

Type

Basic Info

Advantages

Disadvantages

Type

Basic Info

Advantages

Disadvantages

LiPo

  • electrolyte resembles a plastic-like film, which doesn’t conduct electricity but still allows ions exchange

  • are typically included in pouch and prismatic cells

  • Both LiPo and Li-io use identical cathode/anode material and similar amount of electrolyte

  • modern LiPo batteries have become conductive at room temp

  • can be made very thin, so ideal for phones and other consumer electronics

  • more resistant to overcharge; less chance for electrolyte leakage.

  • can be made into more lower profile, flexible, and more robust designs.

  • Lighter than li-ion (do not require a protective case)

  • solid polymer has poor conductivity at room temperature, needs to be heated to at least 60°C (140°F) to enable current flow (dated)

  • LiPo in foil may be less durable than Li-ion in cylindrical package

  • Lower energy density and cycle count than lithium-ion.

  • Expensive to manufacture.

  • Higher cost-to-energy ratio than lithium-ion

Li-ion

  • Nominal voltage of 3.7V

  • Consist of two positive and negative electrodes separated by a liquid chemical electrolyte (limited to a rectangular shape)

  • low maintenance, no memory or scheduled cycling required to prolong its life

  • Most economic in terms of cost-energy ratio is the cylindrical 18650 (diameter-18mm, height-65mm), but if a slimmer pack is needed, choose the prismatic type which has higher cost

  • Longest battery life in comparison to other types

  • High energy density

  • Relatively low self-discharge

  • lack the memory effect (Memory effect - Wikipedia)

  • fragile, requires a protection circuit (Protection Circuits - Circuit Basics, NOTE: read up on this after)

  • aging is a concern, may serve 2-3 years or 5 years depending on the application, however storage in colder temperatures will slow the aging (15°C (59°F)), with a partial charge of 40% (longer than other batteries though)

LiPo vs. Li-ion - Which is better for drones/RC aircrafts?

  • LiPo allows for significantly higher continuous currents than Li-ion, and are generally favoured for higher performance needs (racing/freestyling)

  •  

Sources:

BU-206: Lithium-polymer: Substance or Hype? - Battery University

Is Lithium-ion the Ideal Battery? - Battery University

Lithium Ion Vs Lithium Polymer Batteries - Which Is Better? (freebrowsinglink.com)

The difference between li-ion and li-polymer battery - GensTattu

(188) Li-Ion vs. Li-Po for drones and airplanes? Pros and cons - YouTube

(188) Lithium-Ion (18650 cells) versus Lipo -- which is best? - YouTube

(188) Testing my Li-Ion Drone Battery vs. Li-Po - YouTube