/
Flight Test Crash Causes W24 and Prior

Flight Test Crash Causes W24 and Prior

Owned by Daniel Puratich
Last updated: 2024-04-27
3 min read

Introduction

  • Account for every flight test including and before W24 where we have clear logs for every flight test.

  • How often did we crash?

  • What are the most common causes?

  • We need to be learning from crashes so this document will hopefully tell us what we should focus on.

  • Every time someone asks me what these stats are I always do my best to guess, but I want a solid answer.

  • This analysis will need to be redone in the future as we do more flight tests!

Breakdown

Conclusions

  • Causes of every crash (including duplicates):

    • Weather caused tipping on landings (environmental )

    • Misjudged landing (controls pilot)

    • Motor Order (controls software)

    • Wingspare mechanical integrity (mechanical)

    • Aircraft stuck in mud (environmental)

    • Signal wire soldering (electrical)

    • Accidental disarm (controls pilot)

    • Mechanical Control Authority (mechanical)

    • Motor Mount Broke (mechanical)

    • Signal wire soldering (electrical)

    • Weather caused lack of control (environmental)

    • Controller configuration (controls software)

    • Electronic component failure (electrical)

    • Loose Motor Mount (mechanical)

  • Categorizing Even More (removing duplicates):

    • Environmental (3)

    • Controls (4)

    • Mechanical (4)

    • Electrical (3)

    • Total (14)

    • Fairly even split here I guess lol

  • Total Number of flight tests

  • Percent Crashes

    • 25% (14/56) crash percentage for flight tests, but in reality it’s a bit higher because some of these FTs didn’t happen or we just don’t have data.

    • We should use this number when evaluating if what we have to test is worth the risk?

  • We should be careful about a few cognitive biases when reviewing this data

    • sampling bias

      • we don’t have a lot of data here.

      • differences in airframe have a large impact on likely failure modes.

    • survivorship bias

      • Just because something doesn’t appear in the list doesn't mean it’s not a concern.

      • In my opinion we’ve had so many close calls because of motor order and poor soldering concerns, however, these are underrepresented in the failure modes observed

Related content

Return To Service Procedures
Return To Service Procedures
Flight Tests
Read with this
2024-04-08 AEAC Freestyle
2024-04-08 AEAC Freestyle
Meetings
More like this
2024-07-06 Houston Crash RCA
2024-07-06 Houston Crash RCA
Flight Tests
More like this
Nov 13, 2022 - Phoenix RCA
Nov 13, 2022 - Phoenix RCA
Flight Tests
More like this
2023-03-04 - RCA for Houston Failsafe-Disarm Crash
2023-03-04 - RCA for Houston Failsafe-Disarm Crash
Flight Tests
More like this
2023-04-12 - RCA for Cornflakes Crash
2023-04-12 - RCA for Cornflakes Crash
Flight Tests
More like this